Carneros Pinot Revisited and Re-appreciated – James Melendez



Carneros is a magical AVA that straddles both Napa and Sonoma Counties.

Many of my earliest memories of visiting Napa Valley was going through Carneros. Carneros is a gateway to Napa Valley for many visitors—especially those coming from San Francisco on the 101.

Carneros gave us the first cool climate Pinot Noir – the response is obvious – what hot climate Pinot Noir was the norm? Louis Martini planted Pinot Noir at Stanly Ranch in the late 1940s. Carneros Pinot Noir is thought of as lacking “richness, body and finesses” as Steve Heimoff says in Carneros: A Reflection. He states that since September 1, 2012 only 8 Pinots from Carneros had ranked above 90 points out of 173 – “…a pretty dismal showing” he says. The article is relatively negative and he ends with talking about his last six month score of 90 point and above Pinots… felt like a conciliation prize for Carneros and Pinot Noir.


Some people I know have been equally hard on Carneros especially the Pinot Noirs.   Basically the overall message is that Pinot Noir and Carneros are a mismatch. There have been excuses for why “Carneros doesn’t do Pinot Noir well” and it has come to soil conditions. But the soil content is not uniform and wouldn’t explain that reasoning and also significant sloping and draining patterns.

When I have tasted Pinot Noirs—and especially if I have them on my tasting table and I am tasting many Pinots I am going to bring together regions and not mix and match. The reason is simple. Wine regions as it relates to Pinot Noir differ—I don’t want to be tasting Oregon and Russian River Valley Pinot Noirs at the same sitting or any other region. I think sometimes taster get influenced by one style and it may be at the subconscious level…. Perhaps someone has a preference for fruit intense wines versus leaner styles. As a wine reviewer, I do believe it is paramount to recognize style and to not punish one region over another. I do think it is essential to make the distinction. For me and over time I have truly enjoyed many Pinot Noir and have rated over 90 points not sparingly so but with true merit.


I have been searching for the reasons of Carneros differences for Pinot Noir might not just be soil but more than that—anecdotally every time I visit and especially during growing season there is an noticeable cool breeze—that cool breeze is from the San Pablo Bay. Russian River Valley doesn’t have a San Pablo Bay. Carneros is sunny but cooler than many Pinot Noir growing regions in California. Most Pinot Noir regions have a connection with the Pacific Ocean and that is the evening’s cool down treatment. Carneros has the cooler temps in day as well as evening. I do think this is particularly influential to the region. Please read into this that I never put down one region in favour or another—that would be a wine reviewers quick demise. I still love Sonoma Coast, Russian River Valley, Santa Rita Hills, and my palette lives in the best of all worlds—enjoying all wine regions.

I thought it was about time to write a piece in defense of Carneros Pinot Noir—I do believe now more than ever Carneros producers are doing a very good job with their materials and brining to the market place a point of difference Pinot Noir. Give Carneros Pinot Noir a try—and when tasting use a different lens. I harken back to earlier memories of Carneros and think of the beauty, quality of light year round is amazing. I sometimes on my way back to San Francisco I go down a road to see and feel Carneros when most people are on a rush back to get to the City—it is magical.



Demystifying Wine…One Bottle at a Time from all wine regions around the world.

Read more of my wine reviews:   WORDPRESS

© 2016 James Melendez / James the Wine Guy— All Rights Reserved – for my original content, logo, brand name, rating, rating graphic and award and designs of James the Wine Guy and photographs.   If you have any questions or comments please let me know.

James the Wine Guy also on Facebook, Twitter and most major social medias.

Follow, subscribe, like, browse:






About James Melendez

I love wine and have had the privilege of working in the wine trade as a senior national wine marketing manager for a wine, food and home goods retailer in 30+ US States. I executed into making wine experiential and made 'wines of the world' programme work in a highly regulated framework for a successful business proposition. My "wine" site also incorporates those categories intimately involved with wine such as food, travel and lifestyle. This site incorporates my many dimensions of interest. I love to review and also talk about many aspects of wine. I have been privileged to visit many wine countries and find them enthralling no matter how many times I visit. I love all aspects of wine: viticulture, history, winemaking, brand development, wine regions and many more aspects. This is a living tradition that needs documentation, education, reporting and reviewing. Do I have favourite varieties and styles? I love so many varieties and often it is situational and yet there are time honoured wines that I anticipate and I am passionate about. I like all colours of wine and all styles. I have had a mad passionate affair with sparkling wines and they are always top of mind. Wine nourishes our soul and is the key to connecting with other people at our dinner table. Salute, James © 2014, 2017 James Meléndez / James the Wine Guy— All Rights Reserved – for my original Content, logo, brand name, rating, rating graphic and award and designs of James the Wine Guy. James the Wine Guy also on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, LinkedIn, and other social medias.
This entry was posted in Carneros, Pinot Noir. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.